Really, Lurker, I've destroyed every emotionally-driven point you've tried to make about how Eli supposedly sucks and will never be in the HOF. You inferred he didn't have enough SB's. I showed you one that had none. You inferred he didn't have the stats. I showed you some that had worse stats. You said he wasn't an impact player because Brady was apparently THE team and no QB could have come in and done it from the Pats sideline. I showed you that neither did Eli. The "Facts" are that Eli has the stats, the SB's, and has been PROVEN to be the heartbeat of that Giants offense. That awesome Giants defense didn't put up those points on those scoreboard in those Superbowls that gave you so much embarrassment; Eli Manning's skill at QB did. Tebow the "4th Quarter Comeback Kid"? No, there isn't a person out there that will take ANY QB in the 4th quarter over Eli, including Brady. I've heard that by MANY pundits. Oh, and by pundits, I mean actual players turned announcers. Not idiots in comment sections of 5 year old blogs.
Eli will be in the Pro Football Hall of Fame. So will Peyton, Brady, and, we can debate this, Drew Brees. Difference is, my opinion isn't emotionally-based. I use stats and actually watch the games. Only one person here is trashing a SB-winning QB.