I think he is a natural born citizen but I think he lied in college about where he was born. That is why nothing has been released from college. I think his whole life is a "composite", just like his girlfriend in his book. He is a work of fiction.
He may well be a citizen. He may even have been born in Hawaii, and the statement by the literary agent just a falsehood, or a convenient lie at the time.
However by the known facts of his birth, and the only definition of "natural born citizen" ever recognized by the U.S. Supreme Court, Barack Obama cannot possibly be a natural born citizen of the United States. Obama's father was Kenyan, and transfered allegiance to Britain to Obama upon birth, a fact recognized by Obama himself.
Alexander Hamilton's original draft of the Article II requirement for President indicated only "born citizen", not natural born citizen. Hamilton's sketch indicates in 40 Article IX, section 1:
- "No person shall be eligible to the office of President of the United States
unless he be now a Citizen of one of the States,
or hereafter be born a Citizen of the United States."
Note, the 2nd line even has a preliminary reference to the "grandfather clause".
However, that early Hamilton draft was abandoned. Over this time period, the election of the President was changed from being elected by Congress, to being elected by the people themselves, with "natural born" being a further security to prevent foreign influence, as indicated in a letter by John Jay to George Washington.
Mere birth on U.S. soil, or "born citizen", does not provide any security at all from foreign influence. In fact we've repeatedly seen the effect of this foreign influence in Obama's actions.
Natural Born Defined