He's an asshat. His act plays well in NYC and North Jersey and the Shore, it'd be a disaster on the national and international stage.
And as far as a 25% tariff goes, that's a game that quickly gains players, and sane economists will tell you that the cascading reprisal tariffs after Smoot-Hawley was enacted to 'Protect American jobs' are what turned a big recession into the worldwide Great Depression when the tariffs resulted in the collapse of international trade.
Assuming what you say about the post-Smoot-Holley tariffs is true, I'd say that a lot changes in 80 years.
For example, the US economy has changed.
The Great Depression in UK was nowhere near as bad as it was in the US. Why?
The US was an export-driven powerhouse in the 1920's & 30's. It was much like China is today.
Britain OTOH, had an economy driven by domestic consumption, a reserve currency and an empire.
OTOH, today, the US economy is more like Britain's back then. There is a reserve currency.
And the economy is driven by domestic consumption.
I think the effects of a depression or even serious inflation inside China would be catastrophic.
Millions could starve. I don't think its government would survive very long. The effect on the US would be less serious.
I don't know about Trump's stands on other issues. Second Amendment would be a deal-breaker for me.
But I think he is exactly right on China. And he's the only politician I hear talking about it.
But my opinion around here is already known. The US is at war with the PRC. Anything that weakens the US is viewed
by the CCP as good for China. Conversely, I believe anything that weakens the CCP is good for America.
So I like what Trump is saying. Gun Control would be a deal-breaker for me though.