I absolutely reject anarchy as a different form of tyranny: the tyranny of lawlessness. However, I do hold that an individual does not owe society his life, to be disposed of against his will. I have thought through my premise, and I remain open to new information and arguments. If I truly felt that the individual should pay nothing for the benefits he receives from living in a lawful society, I would not be typing on this computer, having this discussion. That is a far cry, however, from what the draft is. The draft is the government invoking the right to existence while denying that right to its citizens. Because government is formed to protect individual rights, the draft is a perversion of both the government's existence and the inalienable right to life. Remember, your rights stop where another's begin.
I also absolutely reject any sort of idea that the whole is worth more than the individual, as that is a core tenet of statism in all forms. What that amounts to, in relation to the topic, is that some people in society have "more" right to life than others, an indefensible position in a free society.
I do acknowledge that my position may not be popular here, but that makes me all the more appreciate the chance to have the discussion.
Chump, did you ever serve in uniform? Any kind of uniform? Cop, firefighter, Navy cook, Marine rifleman?
I understand your point, but I could not disagree more with you. Along with DAT, I believe that we all have an obligation to serve and go in harm's way, particularly in times of great threat -- WWII probably being the biggest example.
In a time of our history when our fathers were fighting a global war on two fronts, where the Nazi machine and the Japanese empire truly threatened the entire world, I believe that those who went before us also considered it their duty. Many were drafted and many died performing that service of fulfilling that obligation to their countrymen.
I refuse to accept your notion that statism is driving the train when government -- in a time of genuine emergency -- calls its citizens to war.
That said, I also believe that the draft outlived its usefulness long before it actually ended. Deferments and the rest of the bullshit that allowed a lot of privileged, connected kids like Slick Willie to stay in school or outright lie to avoid service did nothing to level the playing field.
Bottom line is, when the country calls, I believe we as citizens have the duty to respond. You clearly don't believe that, and that's fine.
But I'm interested in getting your answer on whether or not you
served.