Here is what the Stratfor report has to say. Let's see if BO was a good negotiatior or a wimp the the Russkies are laughing thier butts of about right now. I know where my money is....
5412
----- Original Message -----
Intelligence Guidance (Special Edition): Sept. 17, 2009 - U.S. Withdrawal on BMD
September 17, 2009 | 1339 GMT
DMITRY ASTAKHOV/AFP/Getty Images
U.S. President Barack Obama (L) and Russian President Dmitri Medvedev in Moscow on July 7Editor's Note: The following is an internal STRATFOR document produced to provide high-level guidance to our analysts. This document is not a forecast, but rather a series of guidelines for understanding and evaluating events, as well as suggestions on areas for focus.
Related Links
U.S.: Backing Down on BMD
U.S., Russia: The Wider Ramifications of Pulling BMD Plans
Ballistic missile defense (BMD) as a military system had no significance for either Poland or the Czech Republic. It was not designed to defend them. Rather, its presence was a symbol to both countries that the United States was prepared to defend them, because it has a vital strategic asset in their countries. The shock in Poland and Czech Republic is about a symbolic shift from their point of view.
What we need to analyze is whether this has any substantial meaning. The question at hand is the state of U.S.-Polish/Czech military cooperation in other areas. Beneath this is the commitment of the United States - outside the context of NATO - for a bilateral relationship, particularly with Poland. Will the United States substitute increased military cooperation for the loss of BMD?
As the news spins that the United States has decided to shelve their plans for BMD system in Poland and the Czech Republic, it seems as if the Americans have given a major concession to the Russians, who have been staunchly opposed to the system.
The timing of the decision is clearly intended to induce Russian cooperation with the United States over Iran. The question is whether there was any prior understanding with Russia regarding this matter. Does the United States have some understanding of a quid pro quo with Russia? The Russian-U.S. tussle over the issue of BMD in Central Europe was never really about BMD. The system never gave Poland anything. It was about the future of U.S.-Polish military cooperation. This is what defines Russia's view of its relationship with the United States.
It is expected that a lot of noise will come out of Poland on the BMD issue, but this by itself has no influence on that unless it is a general redefinition of the U.S. relationship with Poland.
The key here is to focus on U.S.-Russian relations in the aftermath of this deal and focus on it in terms of, first, Russia's next actions on Iran and, second, whether the United States is making substantial shifts on Poland.
STRATFOR will be concentrating on gathering information on this now in Moscow and Washington. That's where this is being played out.