I feel the same way. I don't like Kevin Harvick, Brad Keselowski, or either of the Busch or Dillon brothers. Earnhardt and Johnson aren't really enough to bring me back every week. Who knows?
It doesn't help that NBC does TV coverage for half of the season. You can't match DW, Mike Joy, or Larry McReynolds.
I'm a Carl Edwards fan, but I agree with you, I don't like the Dillons, the Buschs (I think both are hot-headed, arrogant assholes), never really liked either Harvick or Keselowski, Danica is a joke, Stewart and Bowyer bore me (though it was fun to watch Stewart bounce his helmet off Kenseth's hood at Bristol a few years back), Newman is a nice guy, I met him at Martinsville and got to talk to him a bit, but there just aren't any standout drivers anymore like when the Pettys, Allisons, Earnhardts, and Waltrips ruled the track. The cars are all cookie-cutter replicas of each other, just different decals, only 3 different manufacturers instead of the 10 or so there used to be.