I had some unexpected free time this evening, so this update:
Top DUmmie of 2011 (twenty selected):
Atman (Pedro Picasso, the Polaroid Kid)
bobbolink
cali (the bitter old Vermontese cali primitive)
cbayer (the thread slayer)
Chan790
Cyrano (Oscar Wilde, the large-proboscised primitive)
DainBramaged
EFerrari (Doug's stupid ex-wife)
Fire_Walk_With_Me
grasswire
Horse With no Name (Ms Ed, the unappellated eohippus)
iverglas, the anti-gun nut
Judi Lynn (a Yugoista)
kentuck (the bluegrass primitive)
kpete (the kaput primitive)
mike_c
Mineral Man
nadinbrzezinski
Omaha Steve (Omaha's Ed Norton)
progressiveinaction
Proud2BLibKansan (Anne, the dysmenopausal Kansas school teacher)
Raven (the maternal ancestress of the Bostonian Drunkard)
Sarah Ibarruri
SidDithers
Skinner, EarlG, Elad (the Big Three)
Stinky the Clown (the sparkling husband dude)
The Magistrate
The Straight Story
ThomWV (the mountain man primitive)
Taverner
undergroundpanther (the subway cat)
Viva_Daddy
w8liftinglady
William Pitt (the Bostonian Drunkard)
Willie, for spreading around the good name and reputation of Skins's island:
the 9/11 forum on Skins's island
the Atheists' forum on Skins's island
the Israel/Palestinian forum on Skins's island
Alan Grayson (the disgraced ex-congressman)
Andy Stephenson (the late red round one)
cali (the bitter old Vermontese cali primitive)
California Peggy (the poetess laureate of Skins's island)
EFerrari (Doug's stupid ex-wife)
hippywife (Mrs. Alfred Packer)
nadinbrzezinski
ProudDad
Raven (the maternal ancestress of the Bostonian Drunkard)
Redstone (Chief S itting Bull, the bird-smacking stoned red-faced primitive)
Skinner, EarlG, Elad (the Big Three)
Spooked 911
Stinky the Clown (the sparkling husband dude)
The Magistrate
newbie, for an outstanding primitive who's never been in the top twenty:
farleftfist
Fire_Walk_With_Me
malaise (the malarial primitive)
MiddleFingerMom
snoutport
socialist_in_Tennessee
white_wolf
broken elbow, for the whiningest primitive:
Cyrano (Oscar Wilde, the large-proboscised primitive)
demjeepten (formerly the greenbriar primitive)
mopinko (the hypochondrial primitive)
nadinbrzezinski
Omaha Steve (Omaha's Ed Norton)
Stinky the Clown (the sparkling husband dude)
Sub Atomic
Taverner
TheStraightStory
ThomWV (the mountain man primitive)
golden bouncy, for the best bouncies:
11bravo
cali (the bitter old Vermontese cali primitive)
Dreamer Tatum
Firebrand Gary
Horse With no Name (Ms Ed, the unappellated eohippus)
nadinbrzezinski
Sarah Ibarruri
underground panther (the subway cat)
wiley50 (the worthless freeloading bum the wily primitive)
Since there seems some misunderstanding about the criteria for the Willie, the broken elbow, and the golden bouncy awards, it looks possible I may pare down those lists for the ballot. The specific criteria for these awards, given at the beginning of this thread, will also appear on the Official Voting Thread.