But, weren't the bats all ash back then? The bat that got Colvin is maple. Maple bats have been shattering with a high frequency ever since they were introduced.
Dunno about any of that. So move the bats back to ash. If that's the answer.
Bottom line is, shit happens. You stand in a batter's box with some guy whizzing a hard ball within two feet of your head at 95 mph and you're trying to hit the damned ball with a wooden stick, shit sometimes happens.
End of ****ing story.