The Sotomayor cover is highly stylized, and actually a bit disturbing when you see it up close. From a distance its like they tried to shave 30 years off of her, but when viewed up close the cover makes her skin look like rubber stretched over a form. -- Believe me, I know - I delivered at least 50 of these things along the mail route earlier this week. Everytime I saw the cover, I would discover another disturbing area of it.
Like the Sarah Palin cover - the further away you are from it the better it looks.
But I do agree there is different intention of the publisher for both images.