As little use as I have for the whole Obama administration, that article was as ****ed-up as a soup sandwich. The Geneva Convention does not apply to mere criminals, whether in the US, in other countries, or on the high seas, because the reduction of piracy is not "International armed conflict" under the GC. We bend over backwards to apply the conventions in land ops, we could be much more restrictive about treating scum like al Q'aeda as PWs if out leadership chose to go that way.