Full headline: Officer who shot Ashli Babbitt during Capitol riot breaks silence: 'I saved countless lives'
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/officer-who-shot-ashli-babbitt-during-capitol-riot-breaks-silence-n1277736I want to play devil's advocate here. Let us slow down and honestly apply the same standards we do to other police shootings. Watching the video, we see a situation where deadly force is an option. A significant number of people are trying to force their way into a hallway. Injuring or killing one is an option with the hope of scattering the crowd.
Armchair quarterbacking is easy. Was that the best option? I don't think so. Can I honestly say I would not have done the same? No, not honestly. Definitely would like to think I would have realized that shooting into the crowd could just as likely rile them up further as it would scatter them.
I see lots of knee jerk reaction bots popping off "should have complied" responses around the interwebs. There is some truth to that response. Trying to tear down a barricaded door when you know there are armed guards inside is a poor decision that can and in this case, as well as many other, can lead to bad consequences.
My two bits, Lt. Byrd is not a hero, and neither is Ashli Babbet a martyr. Byrd is lucky the crowd didn't push forward after the shot was fired, and Babbet, along with the others in the hallway, should not have been trying to break through the doors. Byrd had an issue with leaving his weapon previously, at minimum, this should be another mark on his record and serious consideration should be taken to see if he should continue to hold a law enforcement position with both of these events on his record. Murder charges are over and above, methinks, but there are probably other charges that may be appropriate.
I think of cases like Botham Jean here in Dallas, the dude who ran away from the Wendy's drive thru with a cop's tazer, the poorly communicated 911 call that got Atatiana Jefferson shot and killed for thinking someone was outside also here in Texas, among other cases. Some of those are justified, some are results of poor decisions by cops or by citizens. Lt. Byrd's choice falls in the middle, I think.