The track record of DOTY voters is pretty embarrassing.
In 2012 they elected a troll who revealed himself right after the election, laughing and mocking the voters.
In 2013 they elected Doug Bulna, Dainbramaged, on the strength of a single post in August, after which he disappeared, never to be seen again.
In 2015 they elected Rolex peddler Randy Shaw, a fake black, another flash (or in his case a flamer) in the pan.
When you consider all the magnificently deranged DUmpmonkeys we've enjoyed, it's embarrassing to think the DOTY honor was wasted on these three losers.