Snuggles, I need four categories, not just three:
1 = Got that ole Reagan feelin' agin
2 = GW Redux
3 = McCain me with a spoon
4 = Stayin' home (I really won't, but I'll be holding my nose and fighting my gag reflex)
So here's how I rate your list thus far:
Michelle Bachmann = 1.5
Herman Cain = 1.5
Newt Gingrich = 3.25
Jon Huntsman = 3
Gary Johnson = 2.5
Sarah Palin = 1
Tim Pawlenty = 2
Mitt Romney = 3
Rick Santorum = 2
Ron Paul - America's Favorite Angry Gynecologist (or AFAG, for short) = 3.5
I reserve the right to change my ratings, based on events as they develop.