51
Breaking News / Worth Knowing, Probably Not Quite Threadworthy 11/8
« Last post by SVPete on November 08, 2026, 12:39:04 PM »NYC Tried to Block ICE’s Shelter Subpoena. A Judge Ordered Enforcement.
https://pjmedia.com/david-manney/2026/11/07/new-york-tried-to-block-ices-shelter-subpoena-a-judge-ordered-enforcement-n4959133
https://pjmedia.com/david-manney/2026/11/07/new-york-tried-to-block-ices-shelter-subpoena-a-judge-ordered-enforcement-n4959133
Quote
New York City fought to keep shelter records from ICE, even after the federal government accepted a screening process focused on people with serious criminal histories. On November 6, Judge Lewis Kaplan ordered enforcement of the subpoena through a special master.
City Hall had its objections heard. It lost.
The dispute concerns a Bronx shelter and federal efforts to determine whether residents are subject to deportation. The city argued that compliance would impose an improper investigative burden and undermine its sanctuary laws. Kaplan found insufficient support for its claim that ICE’s purpose was political rather than investigative.
Protecting private information is a legitimate duty. Using privacy as a reason to reject an enforceable, supervised request requires more than an administration’s dislike of the agency asking. Otherwise, every city could decide which federal responsibilities merit cooperation by consulting the mayor’s campaign platform.
...
Congress expressly authorized immigration officers to subpoena documents relevant to immigration enforcement. Federal law also permits the government to seek a district court’s help when a recipient refuses. Judicial enforcement is written into the statute. President Donald Trump didn’t invent the mechanism because New York elected a socialist mayor who dislikes his policies.
Recent Posts
