My wife's 1999 Honda Accord is on it's 3rd transmission. The original was replaced at 75k by the previous owner with a used one with 20k on it. That one lasted to 85 before it needed rebuilding. It's a known issue that fails beyond the warrenty period. Shit happens.
Juddering is much more violent than just a shudder. It's more like a spasmodic engage/disengage with a loud banging involved. I was driving when it took a dump. It sounded and felt like the rear end was falling out. In reality second gear locked up solid at 80 miles an hour and sorta put a dent in our anniversary plans that year. LOL
I had to repair a transmission once on a 2000 (I think) Grand Prix that was about 2,000 miles out of warranty. I called Pontiac and told them I wanted them to help me cover the costs of the repair. I knew it wouldn't work, but I was pissed. I figured it would help me blow off some steam. I remember the conversation very well because the repair fee was wayyyy more than I had anticipated. Plus I wrote GM a letter about the phone call and transmission as soon as I got off the phone. The conversation went pretty much like below.
Pontiac: How can we help you today?
Me: The transmission went out on my wife's Grand Prix.
Pontiac: And what would you like us to do?
Me: Reimburse part of the money I paid to have it repaired.
Pontiac: How many miles is on the vehicle?
Me: 38000.
Pontiac: Sir, that is 2000 miles beyond the warranty.
Me: Yes. That is correct.
Pontiac: Why would we pay for something outside of the warranty?
Me: Because it was faulty.
Pontiac: How did you determine that?
Me: Did you design it to fail at 38000 miles?
Pontiac: No sir.
Me: Well, it failed at 38000 miles so if you didn't design it to fail at 38000 miles it must be faulty.
Pontiac: We can't pay for something that is outside of the warranty.
Me: I'm not asking you to pay for something that is outside of the warranty. I'm asking you to pay for something that you built that was faulty.
Pontiac: But we have no way of knowing it was faulty.
Me: You have said that you don't build them to fail at 38000 miles, but it did. That means it was faulty. Unless you are lying about not building them to fail at 38000 miles. In that case I want you to explain to me why you build them to fail at 38000 miles.
Pontiac: Ummm…But we don't know if you may have did something to cause it to fail.
Me: I put it in "D" to go forward, "R" to go in reverse, and "P" to park. Is that contrary to its design?
Pontiac: Well, no….during your ownership of the vehicle did you get it serviced at an authorized GM service center?
Me: No.
Pontiac: So we have no way of knowing if you serviced the vehicle properly.
Me: My mechanic is certified and all his service records are computerized. I'm sure he would be willing to forward you the service records.
Pontiac: Ummm…is this the mechanic that repaired the transmission?
Me: No.
Pontiac: So we have no way of knowing exactly what was wrong with the transmission.
Me: Yeah we do. It failed. As to why it failed, I don't know. Based on our conversation so far it possibly failed because GM builds them to fail at 38000 miles.
Pontiac: Sir, as I've previously stated, we do not build them to fail at 38000 miles.
Me: So you agree that the transmission was faulty.
Pontiac: Ummm…no….uh….since an authorized GM service center didn't do the repair we have no way of knowing what was wrong with the transmission.
Me: The transmission repair shop that repaired it is a national chain. I'm sure they would be willing to tell you what was wrong with it.
Pontiac: Yes, but OUR people can't look it.
Me: Yes they can. I have still have all the parts in boxes in the shed. They are more than welcome to come here or I'll send the parts to you if it will speed up the reimbursement.
Then she proceeded to tell me that she was sorry, but she just couldn't help me.