Savage is a ****twit.
To say that 99% of the people with autism are pulling a fraud is absurd to say the least.
I agree with Schade.
But I am torn about this issue and the explosion of diagnoses.
I thought Sowell had a very interesting take on it..
http://www.townhall.com/columnists/ThomasSowell/2008/07/16/autism_curesI know that part of what Sowell says is true. My son was diagnosed with autism in 2005. Those doing the evaluation said that my son met the criteria absolutely and encouraged us to accept services. We did. He was re-evaluated in 2006. That time they said he was borderline but that we should keep the more severe diagnosis, to make sure he could access services if he needed them.
He may fit what Sowell is calling the "Einstein Syndrome". He's bright and he certainly has a ton of geeks in his family tree. But he also has some social issues, sound sensitivities, anxieties and problems with flexible thinking. So his issues aren't just about talking late.
Right now none of it effects his daily life. He goes to a typical school, has friends and all in all is a happy kid.
Does he have autism? After 3 years I still don't know. He was diagnosed at the age of three, just six months after the death of his seven year old brother, one his most favorite people in the world. I'm sure the impact of that on our family made his symptoms appear more severe, but he does have symptoms and did have issues before his brother's death. I am pretty sure though that 10 maybe even just 5 years earlier, he would not have received a diagnosis.
I believe that all very young children really want to please the adults in their life and really want to behave. I don't know if it is necessarily a bad thing to be looking for reasons for misbehavior and taking different approaches with different children. I'm not longing for the good ole days when there were just 'bad' kids in the class and the solution was to keep punishing them over and over the same way without any success.