cali (78,749 posts)
Jezebel has an excellent piece posted on the Gosnell case
Why We Need to Talk About the Horrifying Gosnell Abortion Trial
Philadelphia abortion provider Dr. Kermit Gosnell is accused of running a clinic straight out of the Saw horror franchise: standard practices allegedly included snipping the spines of live newborns with rusty equipment, storing feces in cat-food containers and fetus feet in jars, and overdosing patients, particularly those who were poor women of color. Make no mistake: if these charges are correct, Gosnell is a monster. But his business was able to thrive because of limited access to reproductive choice, not because of reproductive choice itself.
<snip?
Anti-abortion advocates, naturally, are thrilled that Gosnell is on trial. Horrified along with the rest of us, but thrilled at a chance to argue that this case illustrates how unspeakably disgusting abortion is using the most visceral evidence imaginable. "This is not about being 'pro-choice' or 'pro-life,'" Kristen Powers argues in a USA Today op-ed that seems to have drawn significant national attention to the case for the first time since Gosnell's "Women's Medical Society" was raided in early 2010. "It's about basic human rights."
But this case is all about the difference between supporting and blocking reproductive choice.
First, it's important to remember no one (besides his lawyer) is on Gosnell's side. Infanticide is illegal in all 50 states, and Pennsylvania law prohibits abortions after 24 weeks; Gosnell told the authorities that at least 10 to 20 percent of the fetuses found in his clinic were probably older than 24 weeks in gestation. Prosecutors believe Gosnell killed live babies because he wasn't giving women the correct drugs that would have terminated them in the womb. His assistants were often unlicensed and untrained. He was was not a certified obstetrician or gynecologist. No one thinks the Women's Medical Society was a shining bastion of women's health care. We all want him behind bars.
<snip>
http://jezebel.com/why-we-need-to-talk-about-the-horrifying-gosnell-aborti-472647762
http://sync.democraticunderground.com/10022666895What I can't figure out is why when some "doctor" does the same thing they do on a daily basis inside the womb, outside of the womb all of a sudden it is horrible. That is like saying strangling your 3 year old in his own bedroom is not murder, but do it in the living room and it is murder. Same act on the same person but different standards for different settings.
YoungDemCA (806 posts)
1. This is what happens when women, particularly poor women, are severely restricted....
...in their reproductive freedoms.
American policies and culture blames and shames women, and that is especially true of the "pro-life" movement.
K&R
Yeah how dare we shame people who commit murder.
The sad part is American culture no longer shames them, in fact American culture praises them for being brave and doing the "right thing".
