ICE CREAM CAKE!
It's the best kind.
My brother's palette is too "sophisticated" for ice cream cake, so my mom made carrot cake last year. Screw him.
Wait, wait, wait just a minute there, sir!!!
As a young lass, I eschewed the ice cream at friends' birthday parties for a slightly larger slice of the cake. Spaghetti and ice cream made me ill, as a child. Who knows why, anyway, I don't think it's a matter of sophistication as much as a distaste for a cake that is more dairy than sickly sweet bread product.

My family knows better than to order anything less than the supermarket buttercream frosting monstrosity that you find behind those glass cases every day.