I dunno... When mine were little they would compare notes with classmates and friends to find out which areas, or even which houses, gave the best and most. Then they would bug me to hit those places. So it was more like shopping/capitalism than socialism. I would make the three of them debate the benefit of each and settle on one special spot. The oldest would try to bribe the other two into voting her way. Other than that, we went to friends houses and then went home and handed candy out.
I miss the little town where we spent some of their childhoods. The little kids went out right after school for a few hours. Then whoever wanted, kept their porchlights on the the teens would come around. They were the silliest of the two groups and they really went all out on costumes.