Dick Morris was explaining on O'Reilly last night....if I understood him correctly....that the only way the current health care bill in the Senate...that has already been passed to work...is for the House to pass it exactly as it is currently in the Senate.
Any change the House would make to it, would require the bill to go back to the Senate, and then be voted on again.
Is that right? Or wrong?
And I didn't understand the "nuclear holocaust" they kept referring to....except that it would be a really bad thing for the Dems to try to do.
Normally, yeah, that is how it works. There are a couple of possible dodges left in the bag of tricks, though. One would be to actually amend the Senate rules on filibuster, but off-hand I think that might require more than 60, though even if it did, the Dem Senators would not be unanimously for it because some of them would have the foresight to see that what goes around comes around, and they could live to regret that.
The other trick is that a limited class of bills, tax and possibly fiscal ones I think, do not come back to the floor for debate in the Senate after reconciliation, they just get an up or down vote. It would obviously be a travesty to try to wedge this abomination of a bill and all it does into the description of that limited exception (Though bits of it would probably fit), but the entire procedure, like filibuster, is a creature of the Senate's own rules so I don't think it could actually be challenged in court until it was a done deal, and even afterward the outcome of a legal challenge would be a total crapshoot for reasons that could fill a 20-page legal brief.
Either one would probably be suicidal for the Dems in November's Congressional elections, but so far they haven't lacked for hubris. I don't think they'd be able to keep all their Senators together to do either one of these, at some point out of 60 of them, a few will have the basic sense of self-preservation to step away from it. The trick with reconciliation is the most likely since they wouldn't need to keep all 60 on board for that one.