The Conservative Cave
Current Events => The DUmpster => Topic started by: CC27 on March 29, 2025, 09:43:04 AM
-
Horse with no Name
For the legal eagles
Can a writ of habeas corpus be filed on the people who have have been spirited away? Can they be subpoenaed?
I’m just wondering.
https://www.democraticunderground.com/100220187721
WTF are you talking about
-
Habeas corpus, translated literally, means, "have the body." It is a function of law where someone in the justice system appeals to a higher court for relief of some form of procedural injury. Appeals courts are reluctant to grant writs of habeas because they could/would be abused by every guilty party that has nothing to lose just to gum-up the courts.
On a Constitutional level habeas can only be suspended by Congress. Abraham Lincoln violated the Constitution by suspending HC on his own but he was retroactively indemnified. Don't go looking for Lincoln-Trump comparisons in the media, though.
To address Horse's Ass With No Brains, in normal times rights to a habeas petition would require subject matter and personal jurisdiction of the court, i.e. is this particular court competent - you wouldn't go to a civil claims court for a national security issue - and is the petitioner someone over whom the court has power. In other words, as a practical matter, could a court Marshall be sent to retrieve the petitioner without stepping on someone else's turf?
-
I suspect that the brainless horse's ass has been watching some Law & Order.
-
Habeas corpus, translated literally, means, "have the body." It is a function of law where someone in the justice system appeals to a higher court for relief of some form of procedural injury. Appeals courts are reluctant to grant writs of habeas because they could/would be abused by every guilty party that has nothing to lose just to gum-up the courts.
On a Constitutional level habeas can only be suspended by Congress. Abraham Lincoln violated the Constitution by suspending HC on his own but he was retroactively indemnified. Don't go looking for Lincoln-Trump comparisons in the media, though.
To address Horse's Ass With No Brains, in normal times rights to a habeas petition would require subject matter and personal jurisdiction of the court, i.e. is this particular court competent - you wouldn't go to a civil claims court for a national security issue - and is the petitioner someone over whom the court has power. In other words, as a practical matter, could a court Marshall be sent to retrieve the petitioner without stepping on someone else's turf?
Why are liberals so desperate to keep all the illegals they let into the country, anyway?
-
Why are liberals so desperate to keep all the illegals they let into the country, anyway?
They don't care about anything other than power. They don't want to win this legal contest because they love Tren de Argua, they want to win because they want us to lose and that becomes ammunition for later.
-
Why are liberals so desperate to keep all the illegals they let into the country, anyway?
Because they've established the precident of the Census Bureau counting EVERYBODY within the borders of the United States; legal, illegal, living, dead. Everybody. They've done this because apportionment - and it's ability to "redesign" the congressional districts and electoral votes is their only tenuous grasp on power at the moment, and they intend to hang onto it, like SSGT Bunny says.
-
Dear Horse with no Brain,
US writs of Habeas Corpus have no authority in El Salvador. And the current President of the US won't arm-twist them into honoring it.
-
Because they've established the precident of the Census Bureau counting EVERYBODY within the borders of the United States; legal, illegal, living, dead. Everybody. They've done this because apportionment - and it's ability to "redesign" the congressional districts and electoral votes is their only tenuous grasp on power at the moment, and they intend to hang onto it, like SSGT Bunny says.
But they haven't gotten the voting results they expected. Seems weird to want more of what doesn't work, but then again, we are talking about Democrats.
-
I don't know if DU is the place I would look for legal eagles.
-
I don't know if DU is the place I would look for legal eagles.
Like the Devil said to God in the old joke: "Where the Hell [else] are YOU going to find an attorney?"
-
(https://i.imgur.com/orqfM86.png)
Also, what did they do at imgur? I can't simply upload pictures anymore. They think I want to make a meme or something.
-
I don't know if DU is the place I would look for legal eagles.
Only if you were looking to scam the SSDI program.
-
Only if you were looking to scam the SSDI program.
Hey!
You have to admit that the "private attorney general" Steven "Laser" Haas was right on the heels of that elusive Dick Cheney. 24 more bid'ness hours, and he'd have had Cheney dead to rights... :rotf: :rotf: :rotf:
-
Hey!
You have to admit that the "private attorney general" Steven "Laser" Haas was right on the heels of that elusive Dick Cheney. 24 more bid'ness hours, and he'd have had Cheney dead to rights... :rotf: :rotf: :rotf:
That 'I am owed beer and travel money' fella always sounded legally knowledgable, they should ask him.
Letmypeoplecheat always has something to say about legalities, too.
:rotf:
-
I don't know if DU is the place I would look for legal eagles.
That is what you get from people that got their education from watching Matlock and Perry Mason.
-
I don't know if DU is the place I would look for legal eagles.
It's a sanctuary website for illegal eagles.