TeamProg hasn't met many evangelicals. Young Earth Creationists can answer anything between 6000-10000 years old for the earth, and they would probably say the universe is the same age, since Genesis says on the second day God separated the heavens. Then there are Old Earth creationists who believe the word "day" in Genesis is not a literal 24 hour day, but could mean an undetermined amount of time. Most evangelicals with a modicum of Biblical knowledge would answer that man is special enough that instead of just speaking us into being like He did the rest of creation, He sculpted Adam from the dirt in His image.
If Teamprog is lurking, feel free to let me know if you would like me to continue.