I think this is a bit extreme. Regardless of his off the field shortcomings, he earned the Heisman with his play on the field.
I honestly don't have a dog in this fight whatsoever, not giving a tinker's damn about the Heisman Trophy to begin with, but don't you see the value in being a role model for others?
You don't see a parallel with behavior on the field as well as off the field?
Seems to me you can get just about any thug to knock the crap out of another guy on the field and do it legally and brilliantly, qualifying for some kind of sports award, but when you get that same thug to exhibit honorable behaviors off the field versus carrying a gun into a bar or getting arrested for DUI, that person just might stand out a bit more.
He might not even qualify as a thug anymore.