The reasons why we do not want a "public option" is because:
1. If it ever passes, a great number of businesses will unload all of their healthcare policies in favor of the government one, preferring to relieve themselves of the burden and headaches, and to try to offset the high corporate taxes they have to pay. This will inevitably reduce the amount of choices people will have, not increase them.
2. Private insurance companies, or any business for that matter, cannot compete with an entity that does not require a profit to stay in business. The result will be more insurance companies will be forced out of business and all that will be left is the government "option".
3. There are quite a few people (mainly young adults) who simply do not want health care coverage at all, preferring to spend their money on other things. Why then will they be
fined if they don't have health insurance?
4. All of this will ultimately lead to the public option being the only option.
5. Let's not forget about how much all this will cost, which will always,
always be far greater than they first predicted.
6. Always
7. If the public option gets passed, more people will go to their doctors for more innocuous things (thinking they have "free health care" now), which will further strain the system. And that's even if the number of doctors remain constant. However,
that will not be the case. This can only end in disaster.